How Accurate Is "Death by Lightning"? Exploring Facts vs. Fiction in the Latest Netflix Drama
Netflix’s new historical mini-series Death by Lightning begins with a striking question:
“Who is Charles Guiteau?”This simple query sets the tone for a production that blends political intrigue and tragedy while striving to remain grounded in historical authenticity.
The series focuses on the story of President James Garfield’s rise and tragic end. While some dramatic enhancements and timeline adjustments give the show cinematic flair, much of what appears on-screen is closely tied to historical events.
Garfield, portrayed by Michael Shannon, is shown as a modest man who never sought power. The premiere scene—him building a table by hand—serves as a symbol of his honest work ethic and distance from political ambition. Interestingly, that detail reflects reality: Garfield truly preferred his Ohio farm life to the pressures of Washington.
Fact and Fiction Balanced
- The show maintains strong historical grounding despite some dramatization.
- Garfield’s depiction as humble and reluctant aligns with archival accounts.
- Timeline shifts and emotional framing serve storytelling rather than distortion.
Author’s Summary
A thoughtful mix of fact and drama, Death by Lightning stays loyal to the true story of President Garfield while adding just enough cinematic tension to captivate modern audiences.